Doktór Jerszyński Pietras
Adwokaci i Radcowie Prawni
Spółka Komandytowa

Agency Tuesday, News

What is the significance of equitable considerations for an indemnity claim?

We have previously explained that a commercial agent is entitled to an indemnity if: ➡️ they have brought the principal new customers or significantly increased the volume of business with existing customers, and ➡️ the…

What is the significance of equitable considerations for an indemnity claim?
Translated from Polish.Read the Polish original

We have previously explained that a commercial agent is entitled to an indemnity if:

➡️ they have brought the principal new customers or significantly increased the volume of business with existing customers, and

➡️ the principal continues to derive substantial benefits from business with these customers after the termination of the agency contract.

These conditions must be verified first. Beyond them, there is one further requirement on which the validity of the indemnity claim or its amount depends: equitable considerations.

⚖️ Equitable considerations refer to the specific circumstances of the case, which may justify granting or increasing the indemnity, but also reducing it or excluding it altogether.

The Polish Civil Code does not provide an exhaustive catalogue of equitable considerations. It expressly mentions only the agent’s loss of commission as an assessment criterion; however, the court should also take into account the overall context of the parties’ cooperation.

⚠️ However, not every circumstance concerning the agent may be taken into account when assessing equitable considerations.

Case law stresses that relevant circumstances are those connected with the agency agreement and its performance. In contrast, matters such as the agent’s age, state of health, family situation or personal financial position should not affect the outcome.

❗ The allocation of the burden of proof is of crucial importance.

The agent must substantiate the circumstances warranting the award of an indemnity. Conversely, the principal must prove the circumstances that justify reducing or refusing to grant the indemnity.

📌 Conclusion

Equitable considerations represent an essential mechanism allowing the amount of the indemnity to be tailored to the realities of the specific contractual relationship. However, they do not imply unfettered recourse to a general sense of justice. The decisive factors remain the circumstances surrounding the performance of the agency contract, each party’s contribution to acquiring and retaining clientele, and the structure of the agent’s remuneration.

Share

NEWSLETTER DJP

Law from our perspective.

Receive analysis and new publications from our experts. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Let’s talk about your matter.

Understanding your perspective is a good place to start.

Get in touch

Search the DJP website

A topic, name or question

Publications · experts · practice areas · topicsFull search

Enter at least 2 characters to see suggestions.